Equity Education Services

From YTS to the Milburn Report: how did we get here, and will this time be different?

A few times a week I take an early morning walk down to my local woods with a history podcast in my ears. It’s precious thinking time. Many of the episodes take something completely ordinary — the weekend, manners, the suit — and trace how it came to be. Things we now take for granted usually turn out to be the product of radical ideas and social change.

This morning I found myself applying the same question to something that has been in the news for months: youth unemployment. How did we get here? And, with the second part of the Milburn review published this week, how will we actually bring about change?

With the history podcasts I’m simply a listener — I’m not a historian. Youth unemployment is different. I’ve worked in education for over twenty years and, whatever my role, I’ve always kept a foot in the classroom. I’ve been a careers leader, and I’ve championed a change in the way schools tackle disadvantage. As a teacher, I see how the curriculum lands with pupils, and how what is happening in their community and the wider country lands with them too. In my last few years in senior leadership in a multi-academy trust, I also saw what matters most to school leaders — and, quite honestly, it comes down to the attainment and progress scores. That isn’t necessarily what leaders want; it’s what the system holds them to.

Squeezed between the curriculum and the ‘figure’

An enormous amount of time goes into reviewing curriculum: making sure it’s robust and that there’s a clear learning journey. Believe me, middle leaders never hear the end of it. But what we have ended up with is a sandwich — what government says the curriculum must contain on one side, and schools’ pursuit of ‘the figure’ on the other. The outcomes we see today are the result: results that look great for the school, but don’t necessarily give young people what they need to get a job and thrive in it. And I don’t think this is just about schools; colleges and universities have a role to play too.

So I was eager to read the final Milburn report, From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation. Would it contain what I was hoping for? Not only support for employers to take on young people, but a recognition that we need to change how careers and skills are valued in schools, FE and HE — and a way of holding schools accountable for it. Without that accountability, I don’t believe the shift will happen.

We have been here before

Most people my age will remember that youth unemployment is not a new problem.

The Youth Training Scheme (YTS) was launched in 1983 to help young people move from school into work through a mix of workplace experience and off-the-job training. It replaced the earlier Youth Opportunities Programme and was later renamed Youth Training. Trainees received a government-funded allowance rather than a wage, and employers got subsidised, low-cost placements.

Connexions followed in the early 2000s: an information, advice and guidance service for 13 to 19-year-olds (up to 25 for young people with learning difficulties or disabilities), designed to reduce the number of young people not in education, employment or training. Personal advisers worked one-to-one with young people in schools, colleges, youth centres and local Connexions centres, covering not just education, training and jobs but also housing, health, relationships, money and benefits.

From around 2012, Connexions ceased to operate as a national service in England. Funding changed and responsibility for careers guidance shifted to schools, colleges and the National Careers Service. Many of us in schools felt that loss.

What resonated with me

Here are a few things from the report that stood out to me as an educator and as the founder of Equity Education Services.

Almost one million 16 to 24-year-olds are not in education, employment or training — around 13%. Milburn wants that to fall to 5% within a decade.

One passage in the report really spoke to me. Alan Milburn writes:

“I have never particularly liked the term ‘not in education, employment, or training’ (NEET). It may be a useful administrative description, but it too easily becomes a label attached to a young person.”

“The young people I have met want to make something of their lives. They want independence. They want to earn their own money. They want to be useful. They want someone to give them a chance. What too many of them lack is not effort. It is opportunity.”

That matches my experience exactly. The young people I’ve taught have never lacked ambition; what they’ve lacked is a way in.

The report puts it plainly: “the world of work is changing faster than the world of education.” Good GCSE results significantly reduce the risk of becoming NEET, but young people with higher qualifications are not immune. It also describes Britain as “a world leader in higher education but a laggard in vocational education.” In my experience, schools focus hard on academic results but not enough on readiness for work.

Schools clearly have a key role. The report says:

“A knowledge-rich education should sit alongside sport, arts, enrichment, outdoor activity, strong relationships and opportunities for young people to discover interests and aptitudes.”

As the BBC summarised it:

“The interim report describes an education system that is not keeping pace with a fast-changing labour market, prioritising qualifications over destinations and failing to intervene sooner to help those we know will be at risk of becoming NEET later.”

For me, that phrase ‘qualifications over destinations’ sums up the sandwich schools are caught in.

The highlights for me

The BBC has published a handy summary, At a glance: Key proposals from Milburn’s Neets report. These are the proposals that stood out most for me.

A Youth Opportunity Service. A new, locally led service in England would give each young person one named adviser and a personalised participation plan setting out what needs to happen, who is responsible and by when. For anyone who remembers Connexions, this will feel familiar — and welcome.

Schools. Prevention should start early, with primary and secondary schools required to identify and support pupils at risk of becoming NEET. Schools would also be required to offer work experience, and a new performance measure would judge schools on where their pupils end up. This is the accountability shift I was hoping to see.

Colleges and apprenticeships. An extra 150,000 18 to 24-year-olds would study further education courses each year, and college funding would be based on how students do and where they go next, rather than simply on student numbers.

Employers. Incentives would create an extra 170,000 jobs and apprenticeships:

  • £3,000 for employers who take on a young person who has been NEET for six months
  • an extra £2,000 for small businesses with fewer than 50 employees
  • a further £2,000 if the young person is care-experienced or disabled

The report also says large employers should respond to unsuccessful applicants. This one really struck me. Many people won’t realise how hard it is to apply for jobs at the moment. You may or may not hear back, and if you’re unsuccessful, the message is almost word for word the same from every employer: “due to the volume of applications we are unable to provide feedback.” I find that hard myself — so imagine being 19 or 20 with little experience. How are you supposed to improve if nobody tells you what went wrong?

Mental health. Young people who are already NEET should be guaranteed fast-track access to talking therapies and counselling within three months, without needing a diagnosis. A new digital-first mental health service would be the starting point for young people seeking help.

Welfare. An entirely new benefits system for under-25s, with a youth allowance set at the basic Universal Credit rate for under-25s and a higher rate for those living independently.

Will this be a turning point?

I’ll be watching closely to see what changes. If schools are genuinely measured on destinations, not just grades, that could be the moment the sandwich finally breaks. Perhaps one day this will be the subject of a history podcast I listen to on my walk to the woods.

Read the full report: From a Welfare State to a Working State (GOV.UK)

Scroll to Top